CELEBRITIES’
CRIMES
AND PUNISHMENTS
NEED
REVIEW
The
news that Sanjay Dutt stands punished with 5 years imprisonment for the offense
of keeping fire arms is received with mixed response by various sections of
public.
There
are a few offenses pending trial/punishment against Salman Khan and a few other
actors.
There
are also a few Politicians against whom various offenses are pending.
Now,
Sanjay Dutt’s punishment is approved by the Supreme Court itself. But, there
are news and views that he might be or must be pardoned by the Political
establishment under various loopholes in the law.
Sanjay
Dutt is liked by many – and that cannot be faulted. I too am one of his Fans.I
also do not want to see him go to Jail. I want to see him act in many good
movies in future. But, there must be a punishment for keeping dangerous
firearms procured illegally.
It
is the same thing with Salman Khan. If Salman and others are later punished by
the courts but pardoned by the Political establishment, the whole drama of
offence, trial, punishment, appeal etc becomes absolutely farcical. The
Political establishment should not resort to such gross violation of the system
of Justice.
If
the Political establishment right away pardons the person and releases him
without any punishment, it is a definite and open invitation by every
influential and affluent Celebrity to indulge in any crime and seek pardon
through Political establishment. Such precedents are dangerous.
This
is certainly not the way the crime and punishment system must work.
At
the same time, for killing two black bucks in a jungle, sentencing a Celebrity
to 6 years imprisonment also appears to be incorrect.
But
then, Celebrities also run over pavement dwellers and Pedestrians and kill them
in their drunken moods & drunken driving! These are currently treated as
mere TRAFFIC OFFENSES. This too is not correct. The Celebrity offenders in such
cases don’t even pay justified compensations ordered by the Courts. This is
horrible, by any standards.
The
Indian system of justice must look more efficient, Just and fast. Equality of
all in the eyes of the Law must be truly reflected in it.
I
therefore suggest the following methodology.
Replace
the scheme of imprisonment for 5, 6 or 10 years by a VERY SIGNIFICANT FINE as
punishment.
For
instance, for keeping firearms procured illegally, EVEN IF INNOCENTLY, the
person need not be sent to JAIL for 5
years, but must be made to pay ONE previous years’ TOTAL TAXED INCOME as fine
to the Government. There should not be any scope for pardon in such cases by
the Political establishment
The
fine must be paid within 3 months, failing which, his properties must be
confiscated and auctioned.
Ditto
for killing the Black bucks in a forest.
For
running over and killing PAVEMENT SLEEPERS, with his car, the Celebrity must be
made to pay a fine of one year’s total income in respect of each such pavement
dweller killed by him . He cannot just go up the pavement, run over the
pavement sleepers/standees there, killing them or wounding them and get away
with it. The worst of drunken driving should not lead the celebrity’s car onto
a pavement and kill the people there.
Now,
why is such a change in Law needed? Mr. X may be earning a few hundreds of crores of taxable income every year. He must
be a much more responsible citizen than all others. He must respect laws more
and be a more law-abiding citizen. This applies to all Celebrities – and more
so, to Politicians.
If
he kills a few Pedestrians, the lives of the Pedestrians or pavement sleepers
must look as important in the eyes of the law as that of the celebrity.
If
a Celebrity keeps illegal firearms or drugs illegally, he can become the cause
of grave crimes. He must pay for the crime.
Ditto
for killing and eating Black Bucks in a forest area.
But
then, imprisoning the Celebrity for 6 years or even for life serves no purpose
at all, in my view.
It
hurts the lives of many people whose income comes from his success.
In
some cases, whole Industry / companies may suffer.
A
small compensation ordered to be paid to the survivors also makes no real sense
to the persons killed. Even that compensation is not being paid by the
Celebrities.
Any
punishment must therefore serve to open the eyes of the celebrities to the
point that they are accountable for their crimes.
One year’s total taxed income per person killed, I feel, is a
JUST and ADEQUATE FINE to be paid by a celebrity to the Government. About Rs.10
-20 lakhs from this can be paid to the kith and kin of each killed person
(each) and the rest should become the revenue of the Government. If paid to
Central Government, its budget deficit may perhaps be bridged with this revenue
fully.
Likewise,
for going to a forest area and killing 2 Black Bucks against the law, ONE YEAR
INCOME must be the just and adequate fine. Instead, keeping each actor in Jail
for 6 years or more, is a meaningless punishment. Let him act and earn but let
him pay promptly and through is nose. He should feel the pinch of the crime and
punishment.
ONE
YEAR’S TOTAL INCOME is, in my opinion, an undiluted, just, quick and proper
punishment. It may be a few hundreds of crores or a few lakhs. If the celebrity
has run over 10 persons, let him pay 10 previous years’ total Income to
Government as fine.
For
God’s sake, don’t look from the Celebrity’s own angle or from your own liking
for him and his skills.
His
crime deserves a Just, adequate and fast punishment. It must apply to all
celebrities. Readers may voice their support for such a measure. Let us tell
Parliament to amend the Law in such manner, before granting any pardon on the
Celebrities’ punishments.